Revived almost at once
A revival within five years of the original. 292 shows. Before the war this was normal practice — a hit came back the next season, recast and rebuilt, and nobody called it a revival.
292 in the catalogue.
| Lurline | 1870 | earliest staging 1872 |
| Lysistrata | 1925 | earliest staging 1930 |
| Ma Cousine | 1899 | earliest staging 1904 |
| Mandy Patinkin in Concert | 1997 | earliest staging 2001 |
| Mansion on the Hudson | 1935 | earliest staging 1937 |
| Marco Millions | 1928 | earliest staging 1930 |
| Martha Graham | 1945 | earliest staging 1947 |
| Martha Graham and Company | 1943 | earliest staging 1944 |
| Merry-Go-Round | 1927 | earliest staging 1932 |
| Miss Innocence | 1908 | earliest staging 1909 |
| Mixed Marriage | 1911 | earliest staging 1913 |
| More Than Queen | 1899 | earliest staging 1900 |
| Mother Courage and Her Children | 1963 | earliest staging 1967 |
| Mother Goose | 1899 | earliest staging 1903 |
| Mourning Becomes Electra | 1931 | earliest staging 1932 |
| Mrs. Warren's Profession | 1905 | earliest staging 1907 |
| Mrs. Wiggs of the Cabbage Patch | 1904 | earliest staging 1906 |
| Murder in the Cathedral | 1936 | earliest staging 1938 |
| Native Son | 1941 | earliest staging 1942 |
| Naughty Naught '00 | 1937 | earliest staging 1939 |
| Night Hawk | 1925 | earliest staging 1926 |
| No Place to Be Somebody | 1969 | earliest staging 1971 |
| Noah | 1935 | earliest staging 1936 |
| Oedipus Rex | 1907 | earliest staging 1911 |
| Oh, Kay! | 1926 | earliest staging 1928 |
| Olivette | 1880 | earliest staging 1881 |
| On the Quiet | 1901 | earliest staging 1905 |
| Out There | 1917 | earliest staging 1918 |
| Pagliacci | 1944 | earliest staging 1945 |
| Papa Lebonnard | 1907 | earliest staging 1908 |
| Paradise | 1927 | earliest staging 1931 |
| Pariah | 1913 | earliest staging 1916 |
| Peg O' My Heart | 1916 | earliest staging 1921 |
| Phipps | 1913 | earliest staging 1914 |
| Pictures in the Hallway | 1956 | earliest staging 1959 |
| Polly | 1925 | earliest staging 1929 |
| Porgy | 1927 | earliest staging 1929 |
| Power | 1937 | earliest staging 1938 |
| Prince Karl | 1896 | earliest staging 1899 |
| Purlie | 1970 | earliest staging 1972 |
| Rain | 1922 | earliest staging 1924 |
| Riddle Me This | 1932 | earliest staging 1933 |
| Riders to the Sea | 1911 | earliest staging 1913 |
| Robert Emmet | 1902 | earliest staging 1904 |
| Roland Petit's Les Ballets de Paris | 1949 | earliest staging 1950 |
| Rosmersholm | 1904 | earliest staging 1907 |
| Ruddigore | 1927 | earliest staging 1931 |
| Ruth Draper | 1929 | earliest staging 1932 |
| S. S. Glencairn | 1924 | earliest staging 1929 |
| Sailor, Beware! | 1933 | earliest staging 1935 |
| Sally, Irene and Mary | 1922 | earliest staging 1925 |
| Salome | 1918 | earliest staging 1922 |
| San Toy | 1900 | earliest staging 1902 |
| Sapho | 1900 | earliest staging 1904 |
| Semi-Detached | 1960 | earliest staging 1963 |
| Sherlock Holmes | 1899 | earliest staging 1902 |
| Show Boat | 1927 | earliest staging 1932 |
| Shylock | 1853 | earliest staging 1857 |
| Simple Simon | 1930 | earliest staging 1931 |
| Sinbad the Sailor | 1865 | earliest staging 1869 |