Opened on January 15
- 46 productions, 1851 to 2020
| 1851 | The AndalusianBroadway Broughams Lyceum Theatre | |
| 1855 | CinderellaBroadway Broadway Theatre | |
| 1867 | MaritanaBroadway Olympic Theatre | 2 perf. |
| 1872 | Little Red Riding HoodBroadway Woods Museum And Metropolitan | 17 perf. |
| 1879 | H.M.S. PinaforeBroadway Standard Theatre | 175 perf. |
| 1895 | The Heart of RubyBroadway Dalys Theatre | |
| 1896 | Michael and His Lost AngelBroadway Empire Theatre | 13 perf. |
| 1900 | The DegeneratesBroadway Garden Theatre | 36 perf. |
| 1908 | The JestersBroadway Empire Theatre | 53 perf. |
| 1909 | The Barber of New OrleansBroadway Dalys Theatre | 27 perf. |
| 1917 | Love o' MikeBroadway Shubert Theatre | 233 perf. |
| 1919 | A Night in AvignonBroadway Punch And Judy Theatre | |
| 1919 | King ArgimenesBroadway Punch And Judy Theatre | |
| 1919 | StingyBroadway Punch And Judy Theatre | |
| 1919 | The Book of JobBroadway Punch And Judy Theatre | |
| 1919 | The Gods of the MountainBroadway Punch And Judy Theatre | |
| 1919 | The Golden DoomBroadway Punch And Judy Theatre | |
| 1919 | The Laughter of the GodsBroadway Punch And Judy Theatre | |
| 1919 | The Tents of the ArabsBroadway Punch And Judy Theatre | |
| 1919 | The Very Naked BoyBroadway Punch And Judy Theatre | |
| 1919 | Up in Mabel's RoomBroadway Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre | 229 perf. |
| 1920 | The Power of DarknessBroadway Garrick Theatre | 40 perf. |
| 1923 | Give and TakeBroadway 49th Street Theatre | 172 perf. |
| 1923 | The Humming BirdBroadway Ritz Theatre | 40 perf. |
| 1923 | The Lower DepthsBroadway Jolsons 59th Street Theatre | 20 perf. |
| 1925 | The PikerBroadway Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre | 44 perf. |
| 1929 | House UnguardedBroadway Little Theatre | 39 perf. |
| 1929 | Ned Wayburn's GambolsBroadway Knickerbocker Theatre | 31 perf. |
| 1934 | False Dreams, FarewellBroadway Little Theatre | 25 perf. |
| 1935 | Fly Away HomeBroadway 48th Street Theatre | 204 perf. |
| 1946 | The Winter's TaleBroadway Cort Theatre | 39 perf. |
| 1947 | Little ABroadway Henry Millers Theatre | 21 perf. |
| 1948 | Make Mine Manhattan Broadway Broadhurst Theatre | 429 perf. |
| 1952 | The ShrikeBroadway Cort Theatre | 161 perf. |
| 1953 | The Love of Four ColonelsBroadway Shubert Theatre | 141 perf. |
| 1971 | AriBroadway Mark Hellinger Theatre | 19 perf. |
| 1973 | Don Juan in HellBroadway Palace Theatre | 24 perf. |
| 1978 | CheatersBroadway Biltmore Theatre | 33 perf. |
| 1981 | To Grandmother's House We GoBroadway Biltmore Theatre | 61 perf. |
| 2002 | Cats London | |
| 2004 | The RSC's The Taming of the ShrewLondon Sondheim Theatre | |
| 2008 | The 39 StepsBroadway American Airlines Theatre | 771 perf. |
| 2009 | Soul of ShaolinBroadway Marquis Theatre | 21 perf. |
| 2009 | The RSC's A Midsummer Night's DreamLondon Novello Theatre | 28 perf. |
| 2015 | Honeymoon in Vegas Broadway Nederlander Theatre | 93 perf. |
| 2020 | My Name is Lucy BartonBroadway Samuel J Friedman Theatre | 47 perf. |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.