Opened on February 14
- 34 productions, 1860 to 2006
| 1860 | Oliver TwistBroadway Winter Garden Theatre | |
| 1870 | HamletBroadway Olympic Theatre | 72 perf. |
| 1898 | One Summer's DayBroadway Wallacks Theatre | |
| 1905 | HamletBroadway New York Theatre | 1 perf. |
| 1910 | The WitchBroadway New Theatre | |
| 1918 | Sinbad Broadway Winter Garden | 388 perf. |
| 1918 | The Off ChanceBroadway Empire Theatre | 92 perf. |
| 1921 | Peg O' My HeartBroadway Cort Theatre | 88 perf. |
| 1921 | The White VillaBroadway Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre | 18 perf. |
| 1928 | The Clutching ClawBroadway Forrest Theatre | 23 perf. |
| 1933 | MelodyBroadway Casino Theatre | 79 perf. |
| 1934 | Richard of BordeauxBroadway Empire Theatre | 38 perf. |
| 1938 | RoostyBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 1944 | Trial by Jury & H.M.S. PinaforeBroadway Ambassador Theatre | 7 perf. |
| 1945 | SignatureBroadway Forrest Theatre | 2 perf. |
| 1953 | John Brown's BodyBroadway New Century Theatre | 65 perf. |
| 1956 | Someone WaitingBroadway John Golden Theatre | 15 perf. |
| 1957 | Holiday for LoversBroadway Longacre Theatre | 100 perf. |
| 1957 | IntermezzoBroadway Winter Garden Theatre | 5 perf. |
| 1958 | Cloud 7Broadway John Golden Theatre | 11 perf. |
| 1963 | LorenzoBroadway Plymouth Theatre | 4 perf. |
| 1968 | Plaza SuiteBroadway Plymouth Theatre | 1,097 perf. |
| 1970 | Gantry Broadway George Abbott Theatre | 1 perf. |
| 1972 | Grease Broadway Eden Theatre | 3,388 perf. |
| 1973 | WarpBroadway Ambassador Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 1974 | What the Wine-Sellers BuyBroadway Vivian Beaumont Theater | 37 perf. |
| 1977 | Piaf...A RemembranceBroadway Playhouse Theatre | 21 perf. |
| 1979 | Whoopee Broadway Anta Playhouse | 204 perf. |
| 1980 | West Side Story Broadway Minskoff Theatre | 333 perf. |
| 1990 | Man of the MomentLondon Gielgud Theatre | |
| 1991 | Mule BoneBroadway Ethel Barrymore Theatre | 68 perf. |
| 1995 | Love! Valour! Compassion!Broadway Walter Kerr Theatre | 248 perf. |
| 1998 | Hedwig and the Angry Inch Off-Broadway Jane Street Theatre | 857 perf. |
| 2006 | HonourLondon Wyndham's Theatre |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.