Opened on February 23

1863	SatanellaBroadway Niblos Garden	18 perf.
1903	Southern EnchantmentBroadway Haverlys 14th Street Theatre	16 perf.
1914	Along Came RuthBroadway Gaiety Theatre	56 perf.
1914	The Midnight GirlBroadway 44th Street Theatre	104 perf.
1920	Jane CleggBroadway Garrick Theatre	112 perf.
1920	Sacred and Profane LoveBroadway Morosco Theatre	88 perf.
1920	The Letter of the LawBroadway Criterion Theatre	83 perf.
1920	Tick-Tack-ToeBroadway Princess Theatre	32 perf.
1925	AriadneBroadway Garrick Theatre	48 perf.
1925	The Virgin of BethuliaBroadway Ambassador Theatre	16 perf.
1925	Two by TwoBroadway Selwyn Theatre	16 perf.
1925	White CollarsBroadway Cort Theatre	104 perf.
1931	The Venetian Glass NephewBroadway Vanderbilt Theatre	8 perf.
1932	They Don't Mean Any HarmBroadway Charles Hopkins Theatre	15 perf.
1933	Black DiamondBroadway Provincetown Playhouse	16 perf.
1937	PowerBroadway Ritz Theatre	118 perf.
1940	Another SunBroadway National Theatre	11 perf.
1942	IolantheBroadway St James Theatre	5 perf.
1947	O'DanielBroadway Princess Theatre	5 perf.
1955	The Dark Is Light EnoughBroadway Anta Playhouse	69 perf.
1979	Saravá Broadway Mark Hellinger Theatre	140 perf.
1981	HeartlandBroadway Century Theatre	24 perf.
1989	Hizzoner!Broadway Longacre Theatre	12 perf.
1995	Uncle Vanya Broadway Circle In The Square Theatre	29 perf.
2006	The Pajama Game Broadway American Airlines Theatre	129 perf.
2017	Sunday in the Park with George Broadway Hudson Theatre	61 perf.
2026	Mean Girls London

Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.