Opened on May 23

1864	Fra Diavolo/Thrice MarriedBroadway Winter Garden Theatre	24 perf.
1870	The Forty ThievesBroadway Niblos Garden	12 perf.
1898	A Union SoldierBroadway Peoples Theatre
1904	The SouthernersBroadway New York Theatre	36 perf.
1914	Madam MoselleBroadway Shubert Theatre	9 perf.
1921	Shuffle Along Broadway 63rd St. Music Hall	504 perf.
1921	Sun-kistBroadway Globe Theatre	48 perf.
1921	The TavernBroadway Hudson Theatre	27 perf.
1922	Abie's Irish RoseBroadway Fulton Theatre	2,327 perf.
1922	Makers of LightBroadway Neighborhood Playhouse	21 perf.
1927	PatienceBroadway Theatre Masque	16 perf.
1932	On the MakeBroadway 48th Street Theatre	32 perf.
1933	GhostsBroadway Sutton Show Shop	6 perf.
1935	Weather PermittingBroadway Theatre Masque	4 perf.
1940	Keep Off the GrassBroadway Broadhurst Theatre	44 perf.
1944	Career AngelBroadway National Theatre	22 perf.
1945	Foxhole in the ParlorBroadway Booth Theatre	45 perf.
1950	A Streetcar Named DesireBroadway City Center	24 perf.
1951	Idiot's DelightBroadway City Center	15 perf.
1955	Once Upon A TailorBroadway Cort Theatre	8 perf.
1960	Finian’s Rainbow Broadway 46th Street Theatre	12 perf.
1974	Short EyesBroadway Vivian Beaumont Theater	102 perf.
1979	Up in OneBroadway Biltmore Theatre	46 perf.
2000	Notre Dame de ParisLondon Dominion Theatre
2012	PoshLondon Tom Stoppard Theatre
2022	The Glass MenagerieLondon Tom Stoppard Theatre
2025	The Frogs London Off West End

Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.