Opened on May 25
- 21 productions, 1846 to 2016
| 1846 | The EnchantressBroadway Chatham Theatre | 12 perf. |
| 1855 | MaritanaBroadway Niblos Garden | |
| 1903 | A Wife's SecretBroadway Star Theatre | |
| 1903 | The Merchant of VeniceBroadway American Theatre | |
| 1908 | Mary's LambBroadway New York Theatre | 80 perf. |
| 1912 | Mama's Baby BoyBroadway Broadway Theatre | 9 perf. |
| 1916 | The Merry Wives of WindsorBroadway New Amsterdam Theatre | 12 perf. |
| 1920 | An Innocent IdeaBroadway Fulton Theatre | 7 perf. |
| 1923 | Sun-UpBroadway Provincetown Playhouse | 28 perf. |
| 1925 | Odd Man OutBroadway Booth Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1926 | Fakir Rahman BeyBroadway Selwyn Theatre | 24 perf. |
| 1926 | One Man's WomanBroadway 48th Street Theatre | 28 perf. |
| 1932 | Heigh-Ho, EverybodyBroadway Fulton Theatre | 5 perf. |
| 1942 | All the Comforts of HomeBroadway Longacre Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 1948 | Seeds in the WindBroadway Empire Theatre | 7 perf. |
| 1949 | Mr. AdamBroadway Royale Theatre | 5 perf. |
| 1961 | A Call on KuprinBroadway Broadhurst Theatre | 12 perf. |
| 1964 | The Subject Was RosesBroadway Royale Theatre | 832 perf. |
| 1968 | Martha Graham and Dance CompanyBroadway George Abbott Theatre | |
| 2004 | Sight UnseenBroadway Biltmore Theatre | 70 perf. |
| 2016 | Cirque du Soleil ParamourBroadway Lyric Theatre | 366 perf. |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.