Opened on September 3
- 35 productions, 1866 to 2009
| 1866 | Rip Van WinkleBroadway Olympic Theatre | |
| 1895 | The Queen's NecklaceBroadway Dalys Theatre | |
| 1898 | The TurtleBroadway Manhattan Theatre | |
| 1900 | All on Account of ElizaBroadway Garrick Theatre | 56 perf. |
| 1900 | Ben HurBroadway Broadway Theatre | 40 perf. |
| 1900 | Prince OttoBroadway Wallacks Theatre | 40 perf. |
| 1900 | Uncle Sam in ChinaBroadway Star Theatre | |
| 1901 | Don Caesar's ReturnBroadway Wallacks Theatre | 87 perf. |
| 1904 | Mrs. Wiggs of the Cabbage PatchBroadway Savoy Theatre | 150 perf. |
| 1906 | His House in OrderBroadway Empire Theatre | 127 perf. |
| 1906 | The Heir to the HoorahBroadway Academy Of Music | |
| 1906 | The Man from NowBroadway New Amsterdam Theatre | 28 perf. |
| 1907 | PersonalBroadway Bijou Theatre | 38 perf. |
| 1907 | The MoversBroadway Hackett Theatre | 23 perf. |
| 1908 | The ThiefBroadway Empire Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1910 | The International Cup, the Ballet of Niagra, and the EarthquakeBroadway Hippodrome Theatre | 333 perf. |
| 1913 | Lieber AugustinBroadway Casino Theatre | 37 perf. |
| 1913 | Where Ignorance Is BlissBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 1917 | Good Night, PaulBroadway Hudson Theatre | 40 perf. |
| 1917 | The MasqueraderBroadway Lyric Theatre | 160 perf. |
| 1918 | Fiddlers ThreeBroadway Cort Theatre | 87 perf. |
| 1921 | Get TogetherBroadway Hippodrome Theatre | 397 perf. |
| 1923 | Poppy Broadway Apollo Theatre | 346 perf. |
| 1924 | Be YourselfBroadway Sam H Harris Theatre | 93 perf. |
| 1924 | The Passing Show of 1924Broadway Winter Garden Theatre | 106 perf. |
| 1924 | What Price GloryBroadway Plymouth Theatre | 435 perf. |
| 1925 | The Book of CharmBroadway Comedy Theatre | 34 perf. |
| 1929 | Sweet Adeline Broadway Hammerstein’s Theatre | 234 perf. |
| 1930 | That's the WomanBroadway Fulton Theatre | 29 perf. |
| 1934 | The GondoliersBroadway Martin Beck Theatre | 19 perf. |
| 1940 | Kind LadyBroadway Playhouse Theatre | 107 perf. |
| 1941 | Village GreenBroadway Henry Millers Theatre | 30 perf. |
| 1947 | The Magic TouchBroadway International Theatre | 12 perf. |
| 1968 | PantagleizeBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 9 perf. |
| 2009 | Punk RockLondon Lyric Theatre |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.