Opened on September 12
- 40 productions, 1866 to 2024
| 1866 | The Black Crook Broadway Niblo’s Garden | 474 perf. |
| 1870 | HeartseaseBroadway Niblos Garden | |
| 1887 | A Hole in the GroundBroadway Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | |
| 1887 | Dr. Jekyll and Mr. HydeBroadway Madison Square Theatre | |
| 1892 | The Scarlet LetterBroadway Dalys Theatre | |
| 1898 | A Factory WaifBroadway Peoples Theatre | |
| 1898 | IolantheBroadway American Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 1899 | Becky SharpBroadway Fifth Avenue Theatre | 116 perf. |
| 1904 | LettyBroadway Hudson Theatre | 64 perf. |
| 1904 | The Street SingerBroadway American Theatre | 24 perf. |
| 1905 | The Bad SamaritanBroadway Garden Theatre | 15 perf. |
| 1912 | My Best GirlBroadway Park Theatre | 68 perf. |
| 1914 | A Modern GirlBroadway Comedy Theatre | 17 perf. |
| 1918 | Another Man's ShoesBroadway 39th Street Theatre | 12 perf. |
| 1918 | Crops and CroppersBroadway Belmont Theatre | 20 perf. |
| 1919 | Civilian ClothesBroadway Morosco Theatre | 150 perf. |
| 1919 | ScandalBroadway 39th Street Theatre | 318 perf. |
| 1921 | Launcelot and ElaineBroadway Greenwich Village Theatre | 32 perf. |
| 1921 | The CircleBroadway Selwyn Theatre | 175 perf. |
| 1922 | The Greenwich Village Follies [1922]Broadway Shubert Theatre | 209 perf. |
| 1922 | Why Men Leave HomeBroadway Morosco Theatre | 135 perf. |
| 1925 | CourtingBroadway 49th Street Theatre | 41 perf. |
| 1927 | Baby CycloneBroadway Henry Millers Theatre | 184 perf. |
| 1927 | Half a WidowBroadway Waldorf Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1927 | My MarylandBroadway Jolsons 59th Street Theatre | 312 perf. |
| 1927 | RevelryBroadway Theatre Masque | 48 perf. |
| 1928 | Night HostessBroadway Martin Beck Theatre | 117 perf. |
| 1932 | Counsellor-at-LawBroadway Plymouth Theatre | 120 perf. |
| 1933 | Murder at the VanitiesBroadway New Amsterdam Theatre | 207 perf. |
| 1934 | Judgment DayBroadway Belasco Theatre | 93 perf. |
| 1941 | Brother CainBroadway John Golden Theatre | 19 perf. |
| 1944 | Star TimeBroadway Majestic Theatre | 120 perf. |
| 1945 | Devils GaloreBroadway Royale Theatre | 5 perf. |
| 1951 | Bagels and Yox Broadway Holiday Theatre | 208 perf. |
| 1980 | Marcel Proust RememberedBroadway Uris Theatre | 4 perf. |
| 1989 | Freddie Jackson: Up Close & PersonalBroadway Lunt Fontanne Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 2011 | Follies Broadway Marquis Theatre | 152 perf. |
| 2016 | Black to the FutureBroadway Marquis Theatre | 6 perf. |
| 2023 | The Old Man and the PoolLondon Wyndham's Theatre | 26 perf. |
| 2024 | The Roommate Broadway Booth Theatre | 99 perf. |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.