Opened on December 12
- 35 productions, 1785 to 2025
| 1785 | The School for ScandalBroadway John Street Theatre | |
| 1870 | The Black Crook Broadway Niblos Garden | 122 perf. |
| 1898 | Under the DomeBroadway Peoples Theatre | |
| 1904 | Leah KleschnaBroadway Manhattan Theatre | 131 perf. |
| 1904 | The Great Automobile MysteryBroadway Star Theatre | |
| 1905 | Before and AfterBroadway Manhattan Theatre | 72 perf. |
| 1905 | La Dame aux CameliasBroadway Lyric Theatre | |
| 1910 | La Femme XBroadway Globe Theatre | |
| 1921 | The Chocolate Soldier Broadway Century Theatre | 83 perf. |
| 1921 | The Mountain ManBroadway Maxine Elliotts Theatre | 163 perf. |
| 1922 | GringoBroadway Comedy Theatre | 35 perf. |
| 1924 | CandidaBroadway 48th Street Theatre | 143 perf. |
| 1925 | The Man Who Never DiedBroadway Provincetown Playhouse | 22 perf. |
| 1928 | MimaBroadway Belasco Theatre | 180 perf. |
| 1932 | Alice in WonderlandBroadway Civic Repertory Theatre | 127 perf. |
| 1932 | BiographyBroadway Guild Theatre | 267 perf. |
| 1932 | The Show OffBroadway Hudson Theatre | 119 perf. |
| 1935 | GhostsBroadway Empire Theatre | 45 perf. |
| 1945 | Brighten the CornerBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 29 perf. |
| 1951 | Lo and Behold!Broadway Booth Theatre | 38 perf. |
| 1958 | The GazeboBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 266 perf. |
| 1972 | The Last of Mrs. LincolnBroadway Anta Playhouse | 63 perf. |
| 1974 | The Rules of the GameBroadway Helen Hayes Theatre | 12 perf. |
| 1982 | SteamingBroadway Brooks Atkinson Theatre | 65 perf. |
| 1985 | Hay FeverBroadway Music Box Theatre | 124 perf. |
| 1989 | Peter, Paul & Mary "A Holiday Celebration"Broadway Brooks Atkinson Theatre | 6 perf. |
| 1996 | Nine London | |
| 1996 | Whistle Down the Wind Broadway National Theatre, Washington, D.C. (never reached Broadway) | |
| 2002 | Imaginary FriendsBroadway Ethel Barrymore Theatre | 76 perf. |
| 2003 | Les Liaisons DangereusesLondon Playhouse Theatre | |
| 2005 | A Wonderful LifeBroadway Shubert Theatre | 1 perf. |
| 2017 | The ChildrenBroadway Samuel J Friedman Theatre | 63 perf. |
| 2019 | Harry Connick, Jr. - A Celebration of Cole PorterBroadway Nederlander Theatre | 21 perf. |
| 2024 | Cult of Love Broadway Hayes Theater | 59 perf. |
| 2025 | All Out: Comedy About Ambition Broadway Nederlander Theatre | 95 perf. |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.