Opened on December 16
- 34 productions, 1839 to 2024
| 1839 | The Strange Gentleman/ The Roof ScramblerBroadway Olympic Theatre | |
| 1895 | Bonnie ScotlandBroadway Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | |
| 1896 | Castle SombrasBroadway Garden Theatre | |
| 1896 | The Gay Mr. LightfootBroadway Bijou Theatre | |
| 1901 | D'Arcy of the GuardsBroadway Savoy Theatre | 48 perf. |
| 1902 | When Johnny Comes Marching HomeBroadway New York Theatre | 71 perf. |
| 1907 | A Knight for a DayBroadway Wallacks Theatre | 176 perf. |
| 1907 | The Cat And The Fiddle Broadway West End Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 1907 | The Original CohenBroadway Thalia Theatre | |
| 1907 | The Oyster ManBroadway Grand Opera House | |
| 1907 | The Secret OrchardBroadway Lyric Theatre | 32 perf. |
| 1910 | SaphoBroadway Globe Theatre | |
| 1912 | ChainsBroadway Criterion Theatre | 1 perf. |
| 1912 | The RivalsBroadway 39th Street Theatre | |
| 1913 | SchoolBroadway Playhouse Theatre | 1 perf. |
| 1916 | The Married WomanBroadway Neighborhood Playhouse | |
| 1924 | QuarantineBroadway Henry Millers Theatre | 151 perf. |
| 1925 | The WisecrackersBroadway Fifth Avenue Theatre | 13 perf. |
| 1926 | Hangman's HouseBroadway Forrest Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 1936 | Brother RatBroadway Biltmore Theatre | 577 perf. |
| 1948 | Lend An Ear Broadway National Theatre | 460 perf. |
| 1953 | The Prescott ProposalsBroadway Broadhurst Theatre | 125 perf. |
| 1954 | Witness for the ProsecutionBroadway Henry Millers Theatre | 645 perf. |
| 1958 | HamletBroadway Broadway Theatre | 14 perf. |
| 1959 | Goodbye, CharlieBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 109 perf. |
| 1960 | Wildcat Broadway Alvin Theatre | 172 perf. |
| 1976 | The Night of the IguanaBroadway Circle In The Square Theatre | 77 perf. |
| 1979 | Teibele and Her DemonBroadway Brooks Atkinson Theatre | 25 perf. |
| 1982 | Almost an EagleBroadway Longacre Theatre | 5 perf. |
| 1993 | The Red Shoes Broadway Gershwin Theatre | 5 perf. |
| 1999 | Waiting in the WingsBroadway Walter Kerr Theatre | 186 perf. |
| 2004 | The RivalsBroadway Vivian Beaumont Theater | 45 perf. |
| 2007 | The HomecomingBroadway Cort Theatre | 137 perf. |
| 2024 | Eureka Day Broadway Samuel J. Friedman Theatre | 70 perf. |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.