Opened on December 21
- 43 productions, 1868 to 2017
| 1868 | La Chanson de FortunioBroadway Pikes Opera House | 14 perf. |
| 1870 | SaratogaBroadway Dalys Fifth Avenue Theatre | |
| 1874 | The Two OrphansBroadway Union Square Theatre | 180 perf. |
| 1885 | My Milliner's BillBroadway Standard Theatre | |
| 1889 | A Doll's HouseBroadway Palmers Theatre | |
| 1896 | A Man of HonorBroadway American Theatre | |
| 1896 | Darkest AmericaBroadway Peoples Theatre | |
| 1896 | True to LifeBroadway Murray Hill Theatre | |
| 1897 | The Royal BoxBroadway Fifth Avenue Theatre | |
| 1900 | Lady Huntworth's ExperimentBroadway Dalys Theatre | 86 perf. |
| 1903 | The Sacrament of JudasBroadway Princess Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1908 | Peggy MachreeBroadway Broadway Theatre | 40 perf. |
| 1908 | The BattleBroadway Savoy Theatre | 144 perf. |
| 1911 | The StrangerBroadway Bijou Theatre | 28 perf. |
| 1917 | Yes or NoBroadway 48th Street Theatre | 147 perf. |
| 1920 | Sally Broadway New Amsterdam Theatre | 570 perf. |
| 1922 | The Merchant of VeniceBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 92 perf. |
| 1925 | The Master of the InnBroadway Little Theatre | 41 perf. |
| 1929 | Half GodsBroadway Plymouth Theatre | 17 perf. |
| 1931 | Jack and the BeanstalkBroadway 44th Street Theatre | 18 perf. |
| 1932 | Anybody's GameBroadway Bijou Theatre | 29 perf. |
| 1934 | Ode to LibertyBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 67 perf. |
| 1936 | Aged 26Broadway Lyceum Theatre | 32 perf. |
| 1939 | Billy Draws a HorseBroadway Playhouse Theatre | 13 perf. |
| 1941 | Brooklyn, U.S.A.Broadway Forrest Theatre | 57 perf. |
| 1942 | The Three SistersBroadway Ethel Barrymore Theatre | 123 perf. |
| 1943 | Feathers in a GaleBroadway Music Box Theatre | 7 perf. |
| 1945 | Billion Dollar Baby Broadway Alvin Theatre | 220 perf. |
| 1949 | Caesar and CleopatraBroadway National Theatre | 151 perf. |
| 1950 | Out of This World Broadway New Century Theatre | 157 perf. |
| 1954 | Portrait of a LadyBroadway Anta Playhouse | 7 perf. |
| 1961 | Take Her, She's MineBroadway Biltmore Theatre | 404 perf. |
| 1966 | The Star-Spangled GirlBroadway Plymouth Theatre | 261 perf. |
| 1975 | Very Good Eddie Broadway Booth Theatre | 304 perf. |
| 1976 | Barry Manilow on BroadwayBroadway Uris Theatre | 12 perf. |
| 1978 | A Broadway Musical Broadway Lunt-Fontanne Theatre | 1 perf. |
| 1979 | AladdinLondon Lyric Theatre | |
| 1983 | The Tap Dance Kid Broadway Broadhurst Theatre | 669 perf. |
| 2004 | The Royal Shakespeare Company's Romeo and JulietLondon Noël Coward Theatre | 25 perf. |
| 2006 | The Coast of Utopia [Part 2 - Shipwreck]Broadway Vivian Beaumont Theater | 43 perf. |
| 2007 | ShadowlandsLondon Novello Theatre | |
| 2017 | Hamilton London Victoria Palace Theatre | |
| 2017 | Hamilton An American MusicalLondon Victoria Palace Theatre |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.