Opened on December 23
- 60 productions, 1751 to 1982
| 1751 | Othello Broadway Nassau Street Theatre | |
| 1840 | The Cat's in the LarderBroadway Olympic Theatre | 27 perf. |
| 1861 | Ondina!Broadway Barnums New American Museum | 114 perf. |
| 1872 | New Year's Eve, or, False ShameBroadway Dalys Fifth Avenue Theatre | |
| 1889 | The Bells of HaslemereBroadway Windsor Theatre | |
| 1895 | Northern LightsBroadway American Theatre | |
| 1895 | The Notorious Mrs. EbbsmithBroadway Abbeys Theatre | |
| 1901 | The Supper ClubBroadway New York Winter Garden Theatre | 40 perf. |
| 1901 | The WildernessBroadway Empire Theatre | 80 perf. |
| 1905 | SaphoBroadway Herald Square Theatre | 13 perf. |
| 1907 | Deadwood Dick's Last ShotBroadway Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | |
| 1907 | John Glayde's HonourBroadway Dalys Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1907 | Polly of the CircusBroadway Liberty Theatre | 160 perf. |
| 1907 | The Bad Boy and His Teddy BearsBroadway Lincoln Square Theatre | 44 perf. |
| 1907 | The Rocky Mountain ExpressBroadway American Theatre | |
| 1908 | Mr. Hamlet of BroadwayBroadway Casino Theatre | 54 perf. |
| 1908 | What Every Woman KnowsBroadway Empire Theatre | 198 perf. |
| 1911 | Ben HurBroadway New Amsterdam Theatre | 41 perf. |
| 1912 | Miss PrincessBroadway Park Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1914 | Just HerselfBroadway Playhouse Theatre | 13 perf. |
| 1915 | KatinkaBroadway 44th Street Theatre | 220 perf. |
| 1915 | Very Good Eddie Broadway Princess Theatre | 341 perf. |
| 1918 | Atta BoyBroadway Lexington Theatre | 24 perf. |
| 1918 | Back to EarthBroadway Henry Millers Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1918 | Dear BrutusBroadway Empire Theatre | 184 perf. |
| 1918 | Listen LesterBroadway Knickerbocker Theatre | 272 perf. |
| 1918 | Somebody's SweetheartBroadway Central Theatre | 224 perf. |
| 1919 | The WhirlwindBroadway Standard Theatre | 31 perf. |
| 1920 | DeburauBroadway Belasco Theatre | 189 perf. |
| 1921 | The Dover RoadBroadway Bijou Theatre | 204 perf. |
| 1921 | TrilbyBroadway National Theatre | 12 perf. |
| 1923 | The Blue BirdBroadway Jolsons 59th Street Theatre | 33 perf. |
| 1924 | Ladies of the EveningBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 159 perf. |
| 1924 | Old EnglishBroadway Ritz Theatre | 183 perf. |
| 1924 | Topsy and EvaBroadway Sam H Harris Theatre | 159 perf. |
| 1927 | CasteBroadway Mansfield Theatre | 11 perf. |
| 1927 | What Do We Know?Broadway Wallacks Theatre | 23 perf. |
| 1929 | Babes in Toyland Broadway Jolsons 59th Street Theatre | 32 perf. |
| 1929 | MeteorBroadway Guild Theatre | 92 perf. |
| 1930 | The Inspector GeneralBroadway Hudson Theatre | 7 perf. |
| 1931 | Cold in SablesBroadway Cort Theatre | 15 perf. |
| 1932 | HoneymoonBroadway Little Theatre | 76 perf. |
| 1935 | Romeo and JulietBroadway Martin Beck Theatre | 15 perf. |
| 1935 | The Season ChangesBroadway Booth Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 1936 | The Wingless VictoryBroadway Empire Theatre | 110 perf. |
| 1938 | PinocchioBroadway Ritz Theatre | 197 perf. |
| 1938 | Window ShoppingBroadway Longacre Theatre | 11 perf. |
| 1940 | Old AcquaintanceBroadway Morosco Theatre | 170 perf. |
| 1941 | Letters to LucerneBroadway Cort Theatre | 23 perf. |
| 1942 | Flare PathBroadway Henry Millers Theatre | 14 perf. |
| 1944 | Laffing Room OnlyBroadway Winter Garden Theatre | 232 perf. |
| 1945 | Little WomenBroadway City Center | 16 perf. |
| 1948 | Jenny Kissed MeBroadway Hudson Theatre | 20 perf. |
| 1949 | The Respectful ProstituteBroadway Selwyn Theatre | 272 perf. |
| 1953 | Dead PigeonBroadway Vanderbilt Theatre | 21 perf. |
| 1954 | Black-Eyed SusanBroadway Playhouse Theatre | 4 perf. |
| 1958 | A Party with Betty Comden & Adolph GreenBroadway John Golden Theatre | 82 perf. |
| 1970 | Amahl and the Night Visitors/Help, Help, the Globolinks!Broadway Anta Playhouse | 20 perf. |
| 1974 | Good News! Broadway St James Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1982 | Alice in WonderlandBroadway Virginia Theatre | 21 perf. |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.