Opened on December 24
- 41 productions, 1855 to 2001
| 1855 | King CharmingBroadway Broadway Theatre | 34 perf. |
| 1855 | Po-Ca-Hon-TasBroadway Wallacks Lyceum Theatre | |
| 1870 | Barbe-BleueBroadway Grand Opera House | |
| 1877 | The Mother's SecretBroadway Union Square Theatre | |
| 1887 | Paul KauvarBroadway Standard Theatre | |
| 1895 | CarmenBroadway Empire Theatre | |
| 1898 | The Sorrows of SatanBroadway Broadway Theatre | |
| 1900 | A Royal RogueBroadway Broadway Theatre | 30 perf. |
| 1900 | The Giddy ThrongBroadway New York Theatre | 164 perf. |
| 1900 | The House That Jack BuiltBroadway Hoyts Theatre | 18 perf. |
| 1900 | The Village PostmasterBroadway Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1904 | Lady TeazleBroadway Casino Theatre | 57 perf. |
| 1906 | A Broken Man's PromiseBroadway Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | |
| 1906 | Dream CityBroadway Webers Music Hall | 102 perf. |
| 1906 | Peter Pan, or the Boy Who Wouldn't Grow UpBroadway Empire Theatre | 40 perf. |
| 1910 | JudasBroadway Globe Theatre | |
| 1910 | PhèdreBroadway Globe Theatre | |
| 1914 | The LieBroadway Harris Theatre | 172 perf. |
| 1914 | To-Night's the NightBroadway Shubert Theatre | 112 perf. |
| 1917 | General PostBroadway Gaiety Theatre | 72 perf. |
| 1917 | Parlor, Bedroom and BathBroadway Theatre Republic | 232 perf. |
| 1917 | The Lady of the CamelliasBroadway Empire Theatre | 56 perf. |
| 1917 | Words and MusicBroadway Fulton Theatre | 24 perf. |
| 1918 | A Prince There WasBroadway George M Cohans Theatre | 159 perf. |
| 1918 | The Gentile WifeBroadway Vanderbilt Theatre | 31 perf. |
| 1919 | CarnivalBroadway 44th Street Theatre | 13 perf. |
| 1921 | The Married WomanBroadway Princess Theatre | 51 perf. |
| 1923 | The Alarm ClockBroadway 39th Street Theatre | 32 perf. |
| 1923 | The Wild WestcottsBroadway Frazee Theatre | 24 perf. |
| 1924 | The Habitual HusbandBroadway 48th Street Theatre | 12 perf. |
| 1925 | The Greenwich Village Follies [1925]Broadway Chanins 46th Street Theatre | 180 perf. |
| 1927 | SistersBroadway Klaw Theatre | 9 perf. |
| 1928 | One Way StreetBroadway George M Cohans Theatre | 56 perf. |
| 1928 | PoppaBroadway Biltmore Theatre | 96 perf. |
| 1928 | Potiphar's WifeBroadway Craig Theatre | 16 perf. |
| 1930 | Alice in WonderlandBroadway Belmont Theatre | 19 perf. |
| 1931 | It Never RainsBroadway New Yorker Theatre | 20 perf. |
| 1936 | The Water CarrierBroadway 49th Street Theatre | |
| 1950 | Twentieth CenturyBroadway Anta Playhouse | 233 perf. |
| 1963 | The Beautiful BaitBroadway Morosco Theatre | 8 perf. |
| 2001 | A Christmas CarolBroadway Marquis Theatre | 8 perf. |
Titles that are not links are productions of works that never reached Broadway or the West End.