At the Fifth Avenue Theatre
53 productions played this house between 1877 and 1935.
53 in the catalogue.
| The Chimes of Normandy Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1877 | 16 perf. |
| Fatinitza Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1879 | run not recorded |
| The Pirates Of Penzance Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1879 | run not recorded |
| Salviati, or the Silent Man Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1881 | run not recorded |
| Princess Ida Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1884 | 48 perf. |
| The Mikado Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1885 | 250 perf. |
| The Begum Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1887 | 22 perf. |
| Joan of Arc Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1890 | run not recorded |
| The Moth and the Flame Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1893 | run not recorded |
| Gismonda Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1894 | run not recorded |
| Hannele Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1894 | run not recorded |
| Ambition Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1895 | run not recorded |
| His Wife's Father Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1895 | run not recorded |
| A House of Cards Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1896 | run not recorded |
| Pamela Nubile Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1896 | 1 perf. |
| The Governor of Kentucky Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1896 | run not recorded |
| The Speculator Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1896 | run not recorded |
| A Southern Romance Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1897 | run not recorded |
| A Superfluous Husband Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1897 | run not recorded |
| Alexandra Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1897 | run not recorded |
| Divorçons Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1897 | run not recorded |
| Dr. Claudius Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1897 | run not recorded |
| The Devil's Disciple Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1897 | 56 perf. |
| The Royal Box Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1897 | run not recorded |
| A Bit of Old Chelsea Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1898 | run not recorded |
| Hedda Gabler Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1898 | 1 perf. |
| Joan Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1898 | run not recorded |
| Love Finds the Way Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1898 | run not recorded |
| The Royal Box Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1898 | run not recorded |
| Becky Sharp Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1899 | 116 perf. |
| Citizen Pierre Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1899 | run not recorded |
| Three Little Lambs Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1899 | 49 perf. |
| Macbeth Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1900 | run not recorded |
| Marie Antoinette Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1900 | run not recorded |
| Mary Stuart Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1900 | run not recorded |
| Much Ado About Nothing Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1900 | run not recorded |
| Oliver Goldsmith Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1900 | 33 perf. |
| The Countess Chiffon Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1900 | 8 perf. |
| The Ladies' Battle Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1900 | run not recorded |
| Twelfth Night Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1900 | run not recorded |
| Who Is Brown? Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1903 | run not recorded |
| Fighting Bob Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1904 | run not recorded |
| Hush-a-Bye Baby Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1904 | run not recorded |
| Anna Karenina Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1905 | run not recorded |
| Oliver Twist Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1905 | run not recorded |
| The Holy City Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1905 | run not recorded |
| Zorah Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1905 | run not recorded |
| Jeanne D'arc Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1906 | run not recorded |
| The King of Cadonia Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1910 | 16 perf. |
| The Great Game Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1912 | run not recorded |
| The Wisecrackers Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1925 | 13 perf. |
| The House of Ussher Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1926 | 198 perf. |
| Bertha, the Sewing Machine Girl Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1935 | 7 perf. |