Starring Andy Karl
14 shows across 23 years, 1999 to 2022. Taken from the cast list of each staging, so every one is a production they were actually in.
15 in the catalogue.
| Saturday Night Fever Minskoff Theatre | 1999 | 501 perf. |
| Wicked Gershwin Theatre | 2003 | 8,500 perf. |
| Jersey Boys August Wilson Theatre | 2005 | 4,642 perf. |
| On the Twentieth Century New Amsterdam Theatre | 2005 | 1 perf. |
| The Wedding Singer Al Hirschfeld Theatre | 2006 | 285 perf. |
| Legally Blonde Palace Theatre | 2007 | 595 perf. |
| 9 to 5: The Musical Marquis Theatre | 2009 | 148 perf. |
| The Mystery of Edwin Drood Studio 54 | 2012 | 136 perf. |
| Rocky Winter Garden Theatre | 2014 | 188 perf. |
| On the Twentieth Century Theatre not recorded | 2015 | 144 perf. |
| My Love Letter to Broadway Lunt Fontanne Theatre | 2016 | 12 perf. |
| Groundhog Day August Wilson Theatre | 2017 | 176 perf. |
| Pretty Woman: The Musical Nederlander Theatre | 2018 | 420 perf. |
| Moulin Rouge! The Musical Al Hirschfeld Theatre | 2019 | 1,500 perf. |
| Into the Woods St. James Theatre | 2022 | 425 perf. |