Starring Jefferson Mays
8 shows across 19 years, 2003 to 2022. Taken from the cast list of each staging, so every one is a production they were actually in.
9 productions
| 2003 | I Am My Own WifeBroadway Lyceum Theatre | 360 perf. |
| 2005 | I Am My Own WifeLondon Tom Stoppard Theatre | |
| 2007 | Journey's EndBroadway Belasco Theatre | 125 perf. |
| 2007 | PygmalionBroadway American Airlines Theatre | 69 perf. |
| 2012 | Gore Vidal's The Best ManBroadway Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre | 185 perf. |
| 2013 | A Gentleman's Guide to Love & MurderBroadway Walter Kerr Theatre | 905 perf. |
| 2016 | The Front PageBroadway Broadhurst Theatre | 117 perf. |
| 2017 | OsloBroadway Vivian Beaumont Theater | 109 perf. |
| 2022 | The Music ManBroadway Winter Garden Theatre | 376 perf. |