Starring Judy Kaye
13 shows across 49 years, 1972 to 2021. Taken from the cast list of each staging, so every one is a production they were actually in.
13 in the catalogue.
| Grease Eden Theatre | 1972 | 3,388 perf. |
| On the Twentieth Century St. James Theatre | 1978 | 449 perf. |
| Oh, Brother! Anta Playhouse | 1981 | 3 perf. |
| The Moony Shapiro Songbook Morosco Theatre | 1981 | 1 perf. |
| The Phantom of the Opera Majestic Theatre | 1988 | 13,981 perf. |
| Ragtime Ford Center | 1998 | 834 perf. |
| Mamma Mia ! Winter Garden Theatre | 2001 | 5,758 perf. |
| Wicked Gershwin Theatre | 2003 | 8,500 perf. |
| Souvenir Lyceum Theatre | 2005 | 68 perf. |
| Nice Work If You Can Get It Imperial Theatre | 2012 | 478 perf. |
| Rodgers + Hammerstein's Cinderella Broadway Theatre | 2013 | 770 perf. |
| Anastasia Broadhurst Theatre | 2017 | 808 perf. |
| Diana Longacre Theatre | 2021 | 33 perf. |