Demolished, dark, or gone
259 of the theatres in this catalogue are no longer open. Niblo's Garden, where The Black Crook ran in 1866. The Hippodrome, which seated 5,300. Every one of them has productions attached and no building to attach them to.
259 theatres in the catalogue.
| Rialto Theatre | 5 productions | |
| Richmond Hill Theatre | 1 productions | |
| Sam H Harris Theatre | 30 productions | |
| Stairway Theatre | 2 productions | |
| Star Theatre | 103 productions | |
| Stuyvesant Theatre | 2 productions | |
| Sutton Show Shop | 2 productions | |
| Thalia Theatre | 11 productions | |
| 1964 | Theatre 80 St. Marks | 1 productions |
| Theatre Du Vieux Columbier | 2 productions | |
| Theatre Masque | 41 productions | |
| Theatre Of Young America | 1 productions | |
| Theatre Republic | 39 productions | |
| Third Avenue Theatre | 1 productions | |
| Triangle Theatre | 1 productions | |
| Union Square Theatre | 27 productions | |
| Venice Theatre | 2 productions | |
| Venue Name Unknown | 18 productions | |
| Victoria Theatre | 22 productions | |
| Waldorf Theatre | 48 productions | |
| Wallacks Lyceum Theatre | 13 productions | |
| Wallacks Theatre | 186 productions | |
| Waverley Theatre | 5 productions | |
| Weber And Fields Broadway Music Hall | 13 productions | |
| Weber And Fields Music Hall | 3 productions | |
| Webers Music Hall | 16 productions | |
| West End Theatre | 26 productions | |
| Woods Minstrel Hall | 1 productions | |
| Woods Museum And Metropolitan | 40 productions | |
| Worrell Sisters New York Theatre | 8 productions | |
| Xenon | 1 productions | |
| 1869–1881 | Theatre Comique | 4 productions |
| 1823–1895 | Niblo's Garden 3,200 seats | |
| 1863–1908 | Madison Square Theatre | 12 productions |
| 1875–1909 | Manhattan Theatre | 55 productions |
| 1875–1909 | Standard Theatre | 20 productions |
| 1895–1913 | New York Theatre | 61 productions |
| 1882–1915 | Wallack's Theatre | 1 productions |
| 1879–1920 | Daly's Theatre | 1 productions |
| 1907–1925 | Jardin de Paris | 6 productions |
| 1882–1930 | Casino Theatre 1,300 seats | 108 productions |
| 1917–1930 | Greenwich Village Theatre | 58 productions |
| 1893–1930 | Knickerbocker Theatre 1,300 seats | 162 productions |
| 1921–1932 | Jolson Theatre | 2 productions |
| 1904–1933 | Liberty Theatre 1,077 seats | 88 productions |
| 1920–1933 | Times Square Theatre 1,057 seats | 39 productions |
| 1911–1938 | Cohan & Harris Theatre | 2 productions |
| 1905–1939 | Hippodrome 5,300 seats | 2 productions |
| 1906–1939 | Manhattan Opera House | 40 productions |
| 1918–1939 | Vanderbilt Theatre 771 seats | 73 productions |
| 1908–1943 | Gaiety Theatre | 43 productions |
| 1912–1945 | 44th Street Theatre | 87 productions |
| 1918–1945 | Nora Bayes Theatre | 53 productions |
| 1932–1954 | Center Theatre 3,700 seats | 58 productions |
| 1912–1955 | 48th Street Theatre 969 seats | 135 productions |
| 1918–1955 | Central Theatre 922 seats | 11 productions |
| 1923–1955 | Holiday Theatre | 6 productions |
| 1913–1955 | Princess Theatre 299 seats | 115 productions |
| 1906–1959 | Astor Theatre 1,100 seats | 43 productions |
| 1925–1959 | Coronet Theatre | 2 productions |