Recorded again and again
Four releases and up. 207 shows. This is the top of the catalogue by any measure that involves somebody spending money on it twice.
207 shows in the catalogue.
| 1965 | On A Clear Day You Can See Forever | Musical |
| 1944 | On the Town | Musical |
| 2012 | Once | Musical |
| 2017 | Once on This Island (2017 Revival) | Revival |
| 1951 | Paint Your Wagon | Musical |
| 1940 | Pal Joey | Musical |
| 1998 | Parade | Musical |
| 1994 | Passion | Musical |
| 1881 | Patience | Musical |
| 1935 | Petrouchka | Musical |
| 1972 | Pippin | Musical |
| 1923 | Poppy | Musical |
| 1935 | Porgy and Bess | Musical |
| 2018 | Pretty Woman: The Musical | Musical |
| 1884 | Princess Ida | Musical |
| 1968 | Promises, Promises | Musical |
| 1996 | Rent | Musical |
| 1927 | Rigoletto | Special |
| 1933 | Roberta | Musical |
| 1891 | Robin Hood | Musical |
| 2009 | Rock of Ages | Musical |
| 2024 | Romeo + Juliet | Special |
| 1927 | Ruddigore | Musical |
| 1988 | Sarafina! | Musical |
| 1935 | Serenade | Musical |
| 1963 | She Loves Me | Musical |
| 1927 | Show Boat | Musical |
| 1918 | Sinbad | Musical |
| 2011 | Sister Act | Musical |
| 1985 | Song and Dance | Musical |
| 1949 | South Pacific | Musical |
| 2017 | SpongeBob SquarePants | Musical |
| 2006 | Spring Awakening | Musical |
| 1987 | Starlight Express | Musical |
| 1947 | Street Scene | Musical |
| 1984 | Sunday in the Park with George | Musical |
| 1994 | Sunset Boulevard | Musical |
| 1998 | Swan Lake | Musical |
| 1924 | Sweeney Todd | Play |
| 1966 | Sweet Charity | Musical |
| 1913 | Sweethearts | Musical |
| 1999 | Swing! | Revue |
| 2006 | Tarzan | Musical |
| 1966 | The Apple Tree | Musical |
| 1931 | The Band Wagon | Musical |
| 2003 | The Boy from Oz | Musical |
| 1938 | The Boys from Syracuse | Musical |
| 1998 | The Capeman | Musical |
| 1926 | The Desert Song | Musical |
| 1890 | The Gondoliers | Musical |
| 1951 | The King and I | Musical |
| 2002 | The Last Five Years | Musical |
| 2014 | The Last Ship | Musical |
| 2019 | The Lightning Thief | Musical |
| 1997 | The Lion King | Musical |
| 2008 | The Little Mermaid | Musical |
| 2026 | The Lost Boys | Musical |
| 1930 | The Marriage of Figaro | Musical |
| 1968 | The Megilla of Itzik Manger | Musical |
| 1907 | The Merry Widow | Musical |