More than one recording
375 shows carry two or more releases. Every extra recording is a revival, a cast change, a territory, or a remaster somebody thought worth issuing again.
375 in the catalogue.
| Call Me Madam | 1950 | Musical |
| Camelot | 1960 | Musical |
| Can-Can | 1953 | Musical |
| Candide | 1956 | Musical |
| Carmen Jones | 1943 | Musical |
| Carnival! | 1961 | Musical |
| Caroline, or Change | 2004 | Musical |
| Carousel | 1945 | Musical |
| Carrie | 1988 | Musical |
| Catch Me If You Can | 2011 | Musical |
| Cats | 1982 | Musical |
| Cavalleria Rusticana | 1927 | Special |
| Charles Aznavour | 1970 | Concert |
| Charlie and the Chocolate Factory | 2017 | Musical |
| Chess | 1988 | Musical |
| Chicago | 1975 | Musical |
| Chitty Chitty Bang Bang | 2005 | Musical |
| City of Angels | 1989 | Musical |
| Come from Away | 2017 | Musical |
| Comedy in Music | 1953 | Concert |
| Company | 1970 | Musical |
| Conversation Piece | 1934 | Play |
| Crazy for You | 1992 | Musical |
| Curtains | 2007 | Musical |
| Damn Yankees | 1955 | Musical |
| Darling of the Day | 1968 | Musical |
| Dear Evan Hansen | 2016 | Musical |
| Death Becomes Her | 2024 | Musical |
| Die Fledermaus | 1900 | Musical |
| Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | 2005 | Musical |
| Do I Hear A Waltz? | 1965 | Musical |
| Do Re Mi | 1960 | Musical |
| Dr. Seuss’ How the Grinch Stole Christmas | 2006 | Musical |
| Dreamgirls | 1981 | Musical |
| Dreams | 1869 | Musical |
| Elf | 2010 | Musical |
| Eugene Onegin | 1997 | Special |
| Everything | 1918 | Revue |
| Evita | 1979 | Musical |
| Face the Music | 1932 | Musical |
| Falsettos | 1992 | Musical |
| Fanny | 1954 | Musical |
| Faust | 1867 | Special |
| Fela! | 2009 | Musical |
| Fiddler on the Roof | 1964 | Musical |
| Flora, the Red Menace | 1965 | Musical |
| Flower Drum Song | 1958 | Musical |
| Flying Dutchman | 1945 | Special |
| Flying Over Sunset | 2021 | Musical |
| Follies | 1971 | Musical |
| Footloose | 1998 | Musical |
| Fra Diavolo | 1864 | Musical |
| Fun Home | 2015 | Musical |
| Funny Girl | 1964 | Musical |
| Gentlemen Prefer Blondes | 1949 | Musical |
| George M! | 1968 | Musical |
| Ghost The Musical | 2012 | Musical |
| Gigi | 1973 | Musical |
| Girl Crazy | 1930 | Musical |
| Godspell | 1976 | Musical |